Material Selection Cheat Sheet
This page helps users quickly decide:
- whether a material should be saved as a tabulated material or a model material
- which import button should be used in IndexFit
- which upload path should be used when saving results back to the material library
Three-Step Decision
Use these three questions in order:
- Do you want to preserve wavelength points or a model structure?
- Will you continue editing a table or continue editing model coefficients later?
- Is your next action import into a table editor or import into a model editor?
If the answer keeps pointing to wavelength points, choose a tabulated material.
If the answer keeps pointing to model structure and coefficients, choose a model material.
Quick Decision Table
| Your goal | Recommended material type | Recommended entry |
|---|---|---|
Reuse wavelength-point n/k data directly | Tabulated material | Import tabulated material |
| Preserve model type and coefficients | Model material | Import model material |
| Continue editing the refractive-index table | Tabulated material | Table editor |
| Continue editing model parameters later | Model material | Model editor |
| Use the material only for optical calculation | Either type | Use the material that best represents your source |
When to Choose a Tabulated Material
Choose a tabulated material when:
- your primary data is already a wavelength-point refractive-index table
- you want to compare or calculate directly from existing
n/kpoints - you want to import the material into the refractive-index table editor
Typical sources:
- measured refractive-index tables
- imported text or clipboard data
- pointwise fitting results
When to Choose a Model Material
Choose a model material when:
- your primary asset is a dispersion model
- you want to preserve the model type itself
- you want to preserve model coefficients for later reuse
- you want the model parameter UI to rebuild correctly after re-import
Typical sources:
- Cauchy or Sellmeier fitting results
- manually configured model parameters
- saved model-material templates
Which Import Button Should Be Used
In IndexFit there are two explicit import paths:
Import tabulated materialImport model material
Use them as follows:
- If the destination is the refractive-index table, use
Import tabulated material. - If the destination is the model parameter editor, use
Import model material.
Do not use a generic material-picking mindset here. The correct entry matters because the module preserves different kinds of structure.
Which Upload Button Should Be Used
Use the upload button that matches the data you want to preserve.
Upload from the table editor
Use this when:
- the current result should be saved as a tabulated material
- the important output is the wavelength-point table itself
Upload from the model editor
Use this when:
- the current result should be saved as a model material
- the important output is the model type and coefficients
A Practical Rule
If you may later say “I need to continue editing the model”, save a model material.
If you may later say “I only need this refractive-index table again”, save a tabulated material.
Common Mistakes
I want to preserve the model, but I uploaded from the table editor
This is usually the wrong path.
Why:
- the table editor preserves wavelength-point data
- it does not preserve the model structure as the primary result
What to do instead:
- open the model parameter editor
- confirm the model type and coefficients
- upload from the model editor
I only want to reuse a refractive-index table, but I imported a model material
This is also usually the wrong path.
Why:
- a model material is intended to preserve model structure
- the model editor may rebuild the UI instead of keeping your table workflow
What to do instead:
- use
Import tabulated material - continue from the refractive-index table editor
Quick FAQ
Can a model material still be used for optical calculation?
Yes.
If the workflow only needs valid refractive-index values for calculation, the system can evaluate the model at the requested wavelengths.
Does every calculation workflow need tabulated material?
No.
Only structure-sensitive workflows require strict separation. Calculation-oriented workflows can use either type if valid refractive-index results can be produced.
What should I save after fitting if I want to edit coefficients again later?
Save a model material.
What should I save after fitting if I only want to reuse the final n/k table?
Save a tabulated material.